Hello all, here is today's article posted on TheArmoryLife.com. It is titled “Does This Gun Prove That John Moses Browning Got the 1911 Wrong?” and can be found at
https://www.thearmorylife.com/does-this-gun-prove-that-john-moses-browning-got-the-1911-wrong/.
Interesting article. As has been listed here already, after JMB finished the 1911 frame he travel to Europe and worked what some have called the Better 1911 which was the Browning Hi Power. The discussion is mute in my opinion as the 1911 style frame has been converted to so many different calibers from 22LR to 455.
A couple of things to consider
1. The 1911 style frame was actually started in 1902 and progressed to 1911 when it was adopted by the US Military. The German military was also interested as were the Brits interested in the pistol as well, hence the 455 caliber. The US in turn was also interested in the German Luger in 9mm but actual requested the pistol in 45 ACP and to have a grip safety installed. (expensive and rare)
History tells us how all that worked out. The 1911 frame was designed at the that time with the thought processess at that time.
2. The design has proven it worth over the last 100 + years. The design has also shown that depending upon the end user, it can be modified to accomodate various calibers of ammunition.
So the converstion while interesting and a good source of discussion, it all depends on the end user. If you like the design in 45 ACP and desire to have the knock power that the (at that time period) 38 did not have then you are good to go.
If you desire to have a 1911 frame in 9mm with reduced recoil, commonality of most defacto standard ammo, the the 9mm is for you. If you desire to shoot 22 LR in a 1911 frame to practice, save costs but enjoy the weight and style you may do so.
To say that one caliber is better than another is incorrect (opinion) as it depends upon the end user.
I have been trained early on in the 1911 frame and enjoy them immeasurability. I also use, understand and like other pistol and revolvers as well. (Diffently prefer the 1911 style frame and operation)