My point is, there are some folks who just can't master the gun. Abilities to perform physical skills vary. Recruitment, selection, training, and discipline determine the quality of police service. Question is, do we eliminate candidates in the selection process? Do we eliminate them in training? Or do we keep the ones who barely squeek by because they have other useful qualities? The state standards are a pretty low bar to meet in most states. Personnel policies and legal considerations come into play as well. I have recommended termination, and have fired officers who could not qualify, but it is an agonized decision if they are otherwise good people. Most departments have a year probationary period following the academy, which means you have about 17 months to evaluate them.