Hellcat FDE OSP vs. XD-S OSP?

[CheeseMan]

Alright, I'm torn. I've got a little cash to spend and (Assuming I can actually find either) want to buy either an FDE OSP Hellcat or an XD-S OSP with the Crimson Trace optic. Obviously, the XDS will get me a gun and an optic for a price that comes in under the price of the Hellcat. But the Hellcat gets me more on-board ammo. But, on top of the gun, then I have to buy an optic for the Hellcat. Then, what optic do I get? Anybody have any thoughts/suggestions?

 

[David N.]

Alright, I'm torn. I've got a little cash to spend and (Assuming I can actually find either) want to buy either an FDE OSP Hellcat or an XD-S OSP with the Crimson Trace optic. Obviously, the XDS will get me a gun and an optic for a price that comes in under the price of the Hellcat. But the Hellcat gets me more on-board ammo. But, on top of the gun, then I have to buy an optic for the Hellcat. Then, what optic do I get? Anybody have any thoughts/suggestions?

My advice would be to shoot each, if possible then decide.