testtest

My new Prodigy

I have one Springfield, an XDM in 40. Mostly been shooting CZ's in 9mm for my men's league competition. Decided I needed to move up to something made for accuracy and competition. It came down to the Prodigy and the Shadow 2.

To date I have at least 500 rounds through the Prodigy. It shoots very well, accurate with a variety of bullet weights and profiles. I am still working to determine what I will use as a standard load. I did learn that it likes a hair, and I mean a tiny hair, more crimp than normal to allow head spacing and not jamming the brass mouth.

I like the weight and balance of the 5" model and the red dot is good. Last night I was shooting in limited and didn't use my red dot and used the co-witness sights and they are really difficult to see, especially in competition. I doubt I use this firearm in the Limited class again.

Had a few failures are first but haven't had one for a while so I think the hiccups are over. The trigger is good, nice and crisp, not much take up and over travel. I just wish it was a bit lighter and a little smoother.

Now for the downsides I have found thus far. Feel free to disagree, my feelings won't be hurt. I already have changed out the two piece guide rod. Who thought that was a good idea? That was not cheap through EGW, like $80. I don't have large hands at all so getting my right thumb on the slide release is impossible. It is a bit too far forward but mostly way too recessed. The solution is to order a new EGW extended slide release for $50. The mag release button could be a bit bigger and more bold. So far I get along well with it doing a dump and reload, someone will certainly come up with something for that. As for the trigger, EDW can get it down to about 3 lbs or so with a $135 kit.

Here is where my disappointment comes in. I know some of this is optional but it seems like I am already adding parts to get it to function like it really should. A guy in league shoots two Shadows and they are 100% stock with a 2 lb trigger on the Shadow 2. I picked up the Prodigy for $1,400 with the Red Dot and the Shadow was a bit more with no optics so the Prodigy won out. Now I am finding myself spending several extra dollars to get the Prodigy where it should be. That is my biggest complaint and the downside to the firearm.

Anyone else have similar experiences or am I the Lone Ranger.
 
Welcome to the forum.

I have a 5in Prodigy as well and other than a couple of failures to feed in the first 50 rounds the following 3000 have been trouble free. I definitely agree with the two-piece guide rod. I have the Dawson Precision tooless guide rod as well as the 10-8 reverse plug with a GI guide rod. They bother perform the same but I prefer the look of the 10-8 setup. I wear XL gloves but the Prodigy suits my hands just fine. My trigger pull is. Lose to 2.5 lbs and it got there all bull itself. It was a smidge over 4 lbs when I bought it. It’s never been back to SA and other than the guide rod has had zero mods done to it.

As for the Prodigy not being a Shadow 2, I don’t think you’re comparing apple and apples. The Prodigy is effectively a tricked out 1911 and a duty /combat gun, while the
Shadow 2 Is a purpose built competition gun. I think if you were going to run a Prodigy as a race gun then the 4.25 would have been a better choice as it’s generally acknowledged to cycle quicker that the 5in. I know when I run mine in rapid fire drills it feels like it’s having trouble keeping up. However when I use it as a range gun and shoot it at 25+ yds the Prodight clearly says “Hold my Beer,”

And as for spending extra money on a gun, I’m confused. You mean that’s not always the case, some guns just come good to go straight out of the box. If that were true Cajun Gun Works wouldn’t exist. For that matter, there wouldn’t be a dozen high-dollar variants of the fabulous Sig P226.
 
Two piece guide rod, 10-8 performance or EGW slide stop, EGW ignition kit…throw in a Staccato Gen 2 magwell.
Nothing wrong with a stock prodigy.
It’s even better with a little bit of love.
If you’re having fail to feed/fail to eject, send it in for warranty work first.
They’ll fix anything that needs to be addressed.
Then go to town with mods to make it better…

You’ve bought a basement price 2011 double stack style pistol.
It simply won’t have the fit/finish of those double the price. Good news is, you don’t have to spend double the price to get it very close..
 
Back
Top