I have Crossbreed's Reckoning holster for the Hellcat (non OSP). Quite honestly, I wasn't even aware they had a retention tightening screw (until this thread), so I left is as it came. All my Crossbreed holsters, hold several of my compact guns with retention fine.Just emailed Crossbreed, be interesting to see if they put slimmer bushings in the holster or not. Mine are pretty thick on the leading edge like to the point it seems they might need to be fairly crushed to actually put enough pressure on kydex for that to be only retention. Maybe I am expecting too much retention? Always thought it should stay put in holster if held inverted and gently shaken?
I know my Aliengear Cloaktuck will hold my XDs 4.0 just fine like that and draws no problem when needed.
They way my Reckoning holster came, with my Hellcat inside it and held upside down plus shaking it, the holster holds the gun inside without any problems.
Upon reading this thread, I have checked my Hellcat trigger guard, and it's the same shape as when I bought it.
I thank all the posters here for highlighting this issue and it's good to hear that Crossbreed's customer service (as I have yet to use), is being proactive taking this issue head on. I hope that Springfield Armory will do the same, and from hearing from other posters, they seem to also take a proactive stance on issues and problems. I'm interested in hearing from those posters that get a response from them.