I'm biased so my opinion doesn't carry much weight here, but I myself like the PX4 (and the CX4) and XD of course. I have to admit that I'm not really familiar with a few that you listed, so again, not much weight here. I really dig the PX4 Compact Carry with the Langdon Tactical Trigger job and rotating barrel (and the PX4 in general) and I do think it's quite attractive, but I'm also a bit different ;-) . That and the XD are easy to clean as well. BUUUUUUUTTT......again, I'd give a bit more credence to others opinions here.