I guess I am also an odd duck. I am not a Leo/military and in all honesty am never going to be in a sustained firefight. I mean I really can‘t think of a situation were legally I am going to be justifiable going though a couple hi cap mags. cool I get the whole shtf and yes I carry a rifle in the truck and have an extra mag there. But **** the thought of carrying a couple pounds of ammo, gun, knife, multitool, wallet, keys etc sounds horrible. If you want the truth carrying the pistol instead of another mag I would rather have a tourniquet. You are more likely to need that then laying cover fire. If there is a mass casualty event an Ifak will make you more useful then an extra mag. Would also recommend at min a stop the bleed class to learn some basics of how to use an IFAK. USLaw Shield offers a gunshoot wound class and the surgeon that taught ours gave some high speed education on boo boos. Think about it an IFAK can come in handy in multiple situations Car Accidents, slips and falls, industrial accidents.....you know everyday stuff. As for Extra Ammo, I guess Im the meme of the guy sipping coffee at the table convince me otherwise. Hey if you carry extra ammo I am not putting you down, just my situation it doesn’t work for me.
I think that everyone has to find the balance for themselves - to some, just the act of carrying a defensive firearm is on the order of......
The truth of the matter is that one person's overkill is just another's prepared. I think we all fall somewhere along this spectrum.
I've always carried a single spare magazine - a 19-round full-sized magazine that also works in my XDm9 3.8 Compact (which gives me 13+1 in-gun) - not necessarily for the extra rounds, but rather for stoppage reduction. My thinking is along the lines of: "On the worst day of my life, what's the chances that something else could possibly go wrong, too!"
Given that the single most likely route of failure for modern duty/defensive-grade semiautomatic handguns is the magazine, the practice of carrying a spare magazine, for me, becomes cheap insurance.
But definitely,
xdman, I think that more folks should take a deeper look into how to also EDC basic trauma supplies. Although today's news routinely features mass-casualty events, I really don't think that this should be the driving factor. Instead, the simple likelihood of everyday medical events such as motor vehicle collisions and even sporting incidents should give all of us incentive to look at increasing our basic medical-emergency knowledge, skills, and capabilities. For me, a friend's motorcycle accident as well as starting to take my daughter shooting with me prompted, in their own ways, the additions to my EDC (whether it be in-vehicle or on-body).
For those looking to make a fresh start with the new year, I'd recommend that you start gathering up the knowledge you need, now (various municipal entities offer popular "Stop the Bleed" courses), and aim for the month of May ("Stop the Bleed Month") to hit up North American Rescue for steep discounts on proven (
https://www.thearmorylife.com/forum/threads/first-aid-kit.196/ ) gear.