hoythunt1989
Alpha
I'm buying a xds 45 tomorrow and looking for ammo recommendations. It has the 3.3" barrel and I've been told that 230 gr. Doesn't stabilize in that short of barrel so do I need a light bullet?
Look for ammo recommendations
- Thread starter hoythunt1989
- Start date
hoythunt1989
Alpha
How accurate was it
I have a XDs .45 mod 1 . It doesn't keyhole and is plenty accurate for self defense ranges as long as you do your part.
I use Federal HST 230 gr. hollow points. I have never used anything but 230 grain in a .45 ACP.
KillerFord1977
SAINT
You’ll need to try a variety of brands and weights.
Every gun is different.
What may work well in others may not work well in yours
HansGruber
Ronin
You were told wrong. Very, very wrong.
You do not need a light bullet, in fact—particularly when you get into defensive ammo—230gr is the preferred bullet weight, as the greater mass will help ensure better penetration.
So, for practice? Just get some 230gr ball/FMJ. It’s the gold standard.
For defense (if desired)—read this (all of it):
Handgun Self-Defense Ammunition - Ballistic Testing Data
Lucky Gunner tests more than 110 different 9mm, 45 ACP, 40 S&W and 380 ACP handgun self-defense ammunition loads in ballistic gel with analysis and video.
www.luckygunner.com
for what makes one bullet better f out r defense than another, then scroll down to the .45ACP tests. Note that most of the lighter bullets only perform well when in +P—higher pressure—loads, which will mean more recoil and, all things being equal, slower or less accurate follow up shots.
But tell whoever said that a heavy bullet won’t stabilize in a shorter barrel to get bent; they’re an ignorant git who likes to speak out of their nethers. Feel free to quote me.
Bassbob
Emissary
That’s ridiculous. A Shield .45 has a 3.1” barrel and mine has only ever been fed 230gr. Thousands and thousands of rounds. Many classes. Accurate AF.
I shot it very well. As mentioned anything within self defense distance even 10-15 yards shot well. Never went beyond that. I sold it to a friend though because I bought an RO compact that was basically the same niche. He still has it and carry’s it. Nothing but happy comments from him as well.
When it comes to accuracy a lot of that is on the shooter not the gun. Practice makes perfect sort of thing.
Jim Diamantoni
Elite
All I have ever ran in my Kimber Tactical Pro II is 230 gr loads.
Winchester white box or hand loads for target or plinking. Carry loads are Winchester Ranger or Federal HST.
Winchester white box or hand loads for target or plinking. Carry loads are Winchester Ranger or Federal HST.
HansGruber
Ronin
Oh—and by the bye—my last 3” barrel .45 auto—a Colt New Agent—had no problem putting full mags of 230gr Golden Saber, HST, or Ranger-T or bkk blaster grade FMJ/reloads in the chest of a silhouette at 25 yards, despite a 3” barrel…and basically, no sights.
So, yeah…230’s will work fine. I use HST’s in my S&W 325 snubs.
It’s the twist rate of the barrel, not the length, that will determine stabilization.
So, yeah…230’s will work fine. I use HST’s in my S&W 325 snubs.
It’s the twist rate of the barrel, not the length, that will determine stabilization.
"It’s the twist rate of the barrel, not the length". i will be using this statement but in a completely different context. thank you.
Annihilator
Emissary
Jim Diamantoni
Elite
LOL
hoythunt1989
Alpha
Thanks everybody I grab couple different one and see what shoots best
hoythunt1989
Alpha
Well went a picked up the mod 1 45 today but didn't get to shoot it pick up some nobler asp to try 1st
Lexie__M
Custom
I select three types of ammo:
1- Target - So long as descent overall quality as I shoot 100's at a time.
2- Protection - Usually a JHP +p+
3- One the trails/hunting - Solid monolithic ( Bear, Moose, Bison, Puma, Coyote, wyld hog and the worse of all, those conniving low down low life's, two legged snakes that will attack you).
Try a few different types of ammo and see how they feel in your pistol.
Last edited:
