I wanted to update this thread with what I'd written of my winter gloves....
-----
I've only had the PIG FDT Cold Weather Gloves for a single season, so I cannot comment on wear/durability, but they are quite warm (according to my daughter -who is probably the better, between the two of us, to rate this, as she's on her second winter of these). They are water-resistant, but are not waterproof. While even heavy snowfall will not cause soak-through, if there's heavy rain, your fingers will eventually feel they bite. In terms of fit, there is a bit of extra fabric at my fingertips (versus the rest of their FDT lineup), but it's far from unacceptable and, at least in my hands, do not interfere with either the trigger or other controls on my XDms.
Liner wear (I use Outdoor Research liner gloves) is also possible, and also does not cause interference issues for me, at least at this early stage of wear.
Oh, the snot-wiper on these PIG Cold Weather Gloves - yeah....
It's really that good......
Here's my daughter with the Cold Weather Gloves - this was our last outing at the trash-infested public range, so please excuse the backdrop. And no, she didn't purposefully shoot the
Lethal Weapon smiley face on our steel (so that you've got an idea of her size, that's a Tac Strike Quarter-Scale).
I still haven't had a chance to really test out the VIKTOS Cold Shot gloves in their proper context. However, today's windchills were decent, and at least in terms of outside-the-house chores, I wasn't fazed whatsoever. Subjectively, I feel that they're warmer and more dextrous than my Columbia ski gloves, which I've used for several winters for snowplowing and winter-play with our dog, and were previously perhaps my warmest pair.