Benelli reliable ? You bet.Ghost loader here with 6+1 in a Benelli M2 Semi-auto. No ammo extension on it. Reliable? I am sure with all the advances in design, materials, designs, I would think just as reliable if not more than one that would have to be noisibly racked and unless one is an expert, faster.
Well it’s very far from a certainty. Far enough I would never as a civilian deploy that action. I’ll tell you why. I was in a situation once where I was squared off with 3 guys who were in a car. In an attempt to diffuse the situation without it involving prison time I jacked a live round out of the 500 so that menacing sound might deter the guy getting out of the car. It did not. So my choices were to either shoot him or take the butt of the shotgun and drive it through his face. I chose the latter.If I were clearing houses for miscreants I would prefer an M4 shotgun. But defending home and ranch I am confident with my trusty 870.
I agree that racking a pump will not necessadily make bad guys soil themselves, but it will damn sure get their attention. LE training with the pump shotgun is to carry the gun in the cruiser "cruiser safe" or "cruiser ready", with no round in the chamber. You necessarily had to rack the action when deploying the gun. In the late 70's I made a felony stop on one of two cars involved in armed home invasion robberies, with a male driver and female passenger, both armed. I held them at gunpoint from the right rear of their car until my backup arrived. Later the driver told detectives he was going to shoot me if I approached his window, but changed his plan when he heard me chamber a round, and couldn't see where I was. The shotgun was my best friend in many dark alleys and felony stops.
A bayonet would have changed the dynamics....Well it’s very far from a certainty. Far enough I would never as a civilian deploy that action. I’ll tell you why. I was in a situation once where I was squared off with 3 guys who were in a car. In an attempt to diffuse the situation without it involving prison time I jacked a live round out of the 500 so that menacing sound might deter the guy getting out of the car. It did not. So my choices were to either shoot him or take the butt of the shotgun and drive it through his face. I chose the latter.
Incidentally, the guy who’s teeth I drove out of the side of his face is currently in prison for killing an elderly couple across the highway from me in a meth fueled “ episode”.A bayonet would have changed the dynamics....