MsMelissa, I refrained from offering my opinion on whether you should keep it or not, but in the end I'm glad you did. Here's why ...... back in about 1980-1 I was planning a long awaited and planned trip to Wyoming to hunt Pronghorns with my dad. I had several rifles I could've taken, but was really in the mood and had a terrible hankering for a brand new Remington Mod 700 'Classic' in .270 Win. Well I had it ordered and was anticipating getting in time for the trip, but it was delayed for some reason (don't remember why).
Well, it was finally delivered to my front door a couple days before we were to leave and wouldn't you know, it had a small blemish in the wood right behind the trigger guard. Not real bad, but bad enough I almost decided to send it back and not be able to take my new rifle on the biggest hunt of my life till then. But I wanted so bad to take it with us, I swallowed hard and went to the range to sight it in. I couldn't even take it out of the case without feeling almost sick.
Ended up taking the new rifle on the best hunt trip of my life ...... first big trip with my dad, brand new rifle, and filled 2 buck tags and 4 does tags with my new rifle and the thought of that slight blemish faded over the ten days we were out there. To this day that's my very first choice of rifles when I reach into the safe to get one and hadn't even thought of the blemish in years until reading your post about yours.
Yeh, that little blemish is still there, but it doesn't bother me in the least today. I've had too many good times and better memories with that rifle to let it bother me anymore. From your reports of your range day with your new rifle, I'm betting it will be exactly the same for you. Enjoy it as it is and know that it'll never let you down just because it has a little blemish. If it's as good to you as that old 700 has been to me, it won't be long before you make your own blemishes on it here and there, and these today won't even be relative.